In thirty-five days I will lose my job.
For eight years I have held this position, managing editor who writes articles and designs pages and edits everything between the covers, and I have not interviewed or sent out resumes or seen fit to change careers in all that time.
I have known about this job disappearing for a while, but I haven’t done anything proactive about it, because the only thing I really want to do is write.
But how will you feed your family? they say.
How will you make money at something like that?
Will you be able to make it viable?
Many of us, the creatives, know the words of Stephen King as true: “Almost every writer of fiction and poetry who has ever published a line has been accused by someone of wasting his or her God-given talent. If you write (or paint or dance or sculpt or sing, I suppose), someone will try to make you feel lousy about it, that’s all.”
It’s not always the teachers or the threatened peers or the don’t-understand adults who laugh at our talent and the dreams that follow it. It’s often the ones we love, who don’t see the value of painting all day or recording songs in those hours we should be working for “the man” or crafting stories that make people shiver in their beds and sleep with lights on.
The question, right now, today, that makes me feel lousy about choosing a writing career over a working-for-someone-else-so-I’ll-at-least-have-steady-pay is this: Yes, but what will you do?
Yes, but what will I do?
Everyone knows a writer must pursue something else, because writing is a hobby. A luxury. Flowers in a world that needs fruit.
There is this pervasive, dangerous idea about the arts, that the pursuit of an art-life is frivolous and unnecessary and optional. But we know the way that music sinks into our bones, deep, and then burns us to create our own. We know how empty our hands feel when there is no pen and paper, how empty our hearts feel when there is no time left in the margins. We know how our fingers are always tracing the keys of a piano that isn’t there.
We cannot escape an art life, hard as we try. It will eat us alive.
We cannot escape the critics, either. But we must not let them eat us alive.
In his book, On Writing, King tells the story of how, as a teenager, he wrote horror stories and copied them to sell around his high school, and one day the principal confiscated his creation and asked him why he would use his talent to create trash.
He said her voice followed him for a long time, so he’d feel ashamed every time he created another horror story.
When I was a sophomore in college, I took my first creative writing course. The professor was an arrogant man who stood at the front of the class that first day and announced that anyone who got poetry or short stories published would get an automatic A in his class.
My hands shook when I read that first poem to the class, one about an engagement gone wrong. I shook even more when my professor handed the poem back with a whole long note of discouragement.
Too dramatic, he said. Dark. Nobody wants to read love-gone-wrong trash like this.
That semester I got three poems published, including the engagement one, but that professor gave me a B anyway.
It was the first time I met someone who thought he knew best for my life and talent (not the last), and I carried his voice on my back for a while.
But if we who have cracked beneath the blow of a critic want to create, we must shake the demon from our backs.
We must.
Because what the critics don’t understand is that we have to create what lives in us.
Maybe that’s a story about a pond where bodies lie buried beneath scum and every night they come walking. Maybe it’s a drawing of the fearsome creatures you see in your head at night. Maybe it’s a modern dance in a strip club instead of the stage ballet you were trained for.
Whatever we do, there will always be people who believe we’re wasting our talent on trash.
Create anyway.
They will whisper into our weak, What are you doing with your life?
And we will say, Everything.
We were made for this, what we’re doing right now, and nothing they say, none of the fear or discouragement or negativity they heap on us will ever change that.
So instead of feeling lousy about what we do, we must embrace it as something vital and valuable and beautiful for the world.
Because it is.
Do you have a story about a critic? How did you overcome the voice that followed you? What do you believe about your contribution to the world?
Welcome to The Ink Well Creative Community.
The Ink Well Community is evolving. While this used to be a place where I posted a prompt for writers to share their creative works, I have been receiving several inquiries about my process, how I create and read and manage a household with half a dozen little ones. So I thought we could turn this into a community of people who share about the creative process in all its many facets, from where we find our inspiration to when we find time to create (especially if we work other jobs). I’ll be sharing struggles about my creative life and logistical information about my particular creative process and what I’m learning about creativity, among many other things. I hope you’ll weigh in with your own struggles and observations and lessons. Let’s start a conversation. Let’s encourage one another. Let’s live the creative life together.
And if you have your own questions about creativity or process or inspiration, feel free to visit my contact page and send me a note.
I think it must be human’s limbic reptile brain that feels it necessary to denigrate the creative process, just in case the creative human comes up with something too startling (therefore frightening) and upsets the natural order of things. So you are absolutely right. Everyone of us should take joy in our creativity – fly on the tails of the goblin wind. What else are we here for?
Thanks for your input, Tish. I wonder that often: What else am I here for but to share my gifts with the world?
YES!
I would read anything you write, and cheer you on along the way! I’m wondering if you’ve read The Icarus Effect by Seth Godin? Also The War of Art, I can’t think of the author right now. Two great reads about this topic.
I have read The War of Art, but not The Icarus Deception. Going on my list! And thank you for the encouragement!
Sigh….I meant The Icarus Deception. And The War of Art is by Stephen Pressfield. En route for the holidays makes commenting tricky!